Skip to main content

Table 3 Major advantages and disadvantages of various echocardiographic techniques for assessing SV cardiac function

From: Transthoracic echocardiographic assessment of ventricular function in functional single ventricle: a comprehensive review

 

Major advantages

Major disadvantages

2DE

Wide range of applications

Easy acces

Dependent on geometric assumptions

Susceptible to load

Low sensitivity

Used more to assess overall rather than local cardiac function

TDI

Parameters Moderately Correlated with VEDP Measured by Cardiac Catheterization

There was no statistically significant correlation between EF measured by CMR and Tei index

Angle dependence

RT-3DE

Provides a full range of 3D images of the heart

Real-time observation

Parameters correlate well with CMR-EF

Highly dependent on image quality

Large SV cannot be included in a single view

Sensitive to changes in position, respiration, and heart rate

RT-3DE tends to underestimate right ventricular volume in children with SRV

2D-STI

2D-STI-Measured strain rates closely correlate with VEDP measured by cardiac catheterization

2D-STI measured strain in good agreement with CMR

Depends on image quality

Cross-plane motion loss tracking phenomenon

PSL

MWI may be a more sensitive indicator of myocardial damage than ejection fraction and may predict exercise capacity

Few studies have been done on the subject

Role is uncertain

3D-STI

Torsion measured with 3D-STI has good reproducibility and is age-independent

Highly dependent on image quality

Complex post-processing and expensive equipment

VVI

Provides multidirectional myocardial motion information

Strain rate measured by VVI closely correlates with Max (dp/ dt) measured by cardiac catheterization

Few relevant studies

  1. Abbreviations: TTE, transthoracic chocardiographic;2DE, two-dimensional echocardiography; TDI, tissue doppler imaging; VEDP, ventricular end-diastolic pressure; CMR, cardiac magnetic resonance; EF, ejection fraction; RT-3DE, real-time 3-dimensional echocardiography;2D-STI, two-dimensional speckle tracking imaging; SRV, single right ventricle; PSL, Pressure-strain loops; MWI, myocardial work index;3D-STI, three-dimensional speckle tracking imaging; VVI, velocity vector imaging